Historical version
This page records design, operation, or validation facts from an earlier release. It is not current V7.17.3 guidance. Start from the documentation hub for current instructions.
Codex Cross-Project Long-Term Engineering Assistant V6.3 Validation Report¶
Subject¶
- Version: 6.3.0
- Target host: native Windows Codex CLI 0.150.1
- Recommended form: account-level Plugin
- Upgrade baselines: V6.1.0 and V6.2.0
- Event contract: TaskOutcomeEvent 2.0
- Automatic subagent ceiling:
gpt-5.6-terra + high - Execution authorization:
NONE
In-Package Validation¶
| Item | Result | Evidence Entry |
|---|---|---|
| JSON/TOML parsing and Python compilation | PASS | scripts/validate-v63.py |
| Neutral language and structural semantics | PASS | scripts/semantic-lint.py |
| Skill routing cases | PASS, 35 | scripts/routing-eval.py validate |
| Package unit and regression tests | PASS, 53/53 | tests/test_*.py |
| Shared runtime regressions | PASS, 6/6 | runtime/tests/test_*.py |
| Installation transactions and fault injection | PASS, targeted | tests/test_package_manager_security.py |
| Lifecycle and self-observation quality | PASS, targeted | tests/test_v60_deterministic_observation.py |
| Deterministic ZIP and release-evidence contract | PASS, targeted | tests/test_v63_release_delivery.py |
| Evolution Proposal safety boundary | PASS, targeted | tests/test_v51_controlled_evolution.py |
Every PASS in validate-v63.py derives from commands and suites executed in this run. Unexecuted real-host items remain NOT_EXECUTED; constants do not substitute for evidence.
Isolated Real-Machine Upgrade Loop¶
Completed with real Codex CLI 0.150.1 under a short isolated account path:
V6.1.0 installed/enabled
-> V6.3.0 install + verify + Plugin list readback
-> V6.3 uninstall
-> V6.1.0 installed/enabled restored
Result: PASS.
- V6.3 readback: installed=true, enabled=true, version=6.3.0.
- After uninstall: installed=true, enabled=true, version=6.1.0.
- No active transaction journal remained after V6.3 commit.
- The isolated upgrade backup was retained.
- The real account
CODEX_HOMEwas not written during this isolated test.
The first isolated attempt used a deep workspace path and was blocked by V6.1's legacy long-path limitation before V6.3 wrote anything. Retesting with a short isolated path passed.
Independent Review¶
Preimplementation review identified gates for release evidence, real lifecycle, reproducible ZIP, observation completeness, and Reviewer attribution. Two logically read-only specialist Reviewers covered state/concurrency and test/delivery after implementation.
Major resolved findings:
- per-target journal ownership for install, repository install, and uninstall;
- persistence of Plugin and Marketplace state before uninstall unregistration;
- complete Marketplace staging with expected target hash recorded before replacement;
- lifecycle aggregation by
session_id + task_id, with cross-session task conflicts entering the evidence gate; - duplicate event IDs no longer hiding later chain damage;
- stale-lock logic no longer deleting a lock held by a live process based only on age;
- validation counts and PASS states derived from actual output;
- V6.3 release and audit files included in the package;
- release evidence covers content tampering, illegal paths, correct/incorrect HMAC keys, and cross-parent lifecycle ordering errors.
Review was logically read-only. TaskOutcomeEvent readback reported gpt-5.6-luna; actual reasoning effort was not supplied by the host and remained unverified.
Formal Host Acceptance¶
Formal account acceptance on native Windows Codex CLI 0.150.1: PASS.
- V6.1.0 -> V6.3.0 Plugin transaction upgrade succeeded.
codex plugin list --jsonreadback: installed=true, enabled=true, version=6.3.0.- Ten Skills, seven Reviewers, and six Hooks were discoverable; Reviewer TOML did not fix a model.
- Main configuration hash was unchanged and every preupgrade account Skill remained.
- Historical project-context file count did not decrease and the upgrade backup remained.
- No active transaction marker remained, and targets were not Junctions, Reparse Points, or symlinks.
- A new read-only acceptance task started a
cp_review_test_deliveryReviewer. - Diagnostic observation reported
gpt-5.6-luna; the main-agent model configuration did not change. - One session produced TURN_OPENED, SUBAGENT_STARTED, SUBAGENT_STOPPED, TASK_COMPLETED, and SESSION_ENDED.
- Five TaskOutcomeEvent 2.0 records had a continuous hash chain and matching
project_id + repo_fingerprint. - SessionEnd completed within the three-second Hook limit; Windows used
cp_hook.cmdwithout extrapython3.exe.
The formal ZIP hash, byte-identical double build, hashes of the host evidence, and tamper verification are bound by an external machine proof. Without a valid machine proof, the artifact must not be called verified.
Security Boundaries¶
execution_authorization=NONE.- No automatic modification of Skills, Reviewers, main-agent models, or business code.
- No automatic acceptance or implementation of Evolution Proposals.
- No automatic commit, push, deployment, restart, or production operation.
- Project aggregation validates both
project_id + repo_fingerprint. - Historical Events, Snapshots, Assessments, Proposals, and upgrade backups survive ordinary upgrade and uninstall.