Historical version
This page records design, operation, or validation facts from an earlier release. It is not current V7.17.3 guidance. Start from the documentation hub for current instructions.
V7.4.0 Independent Review Report¶
Status: pre-implementation and two post-implementation logical-readonly review rounds completed with no open blocking finding.
The pre-review froze TaskOutcomeEvent V2 and required an independent hashed budget ledger, explicit reservations, no guessed lifecycle association, trusted host proof for actual profiles, and fail-closed locking, corruption, and unknown-schema behavior.
The first post-review found late events after close, calibration not bound to completed reservations, unbounded metrics, failure to repair a V7.3 malformed Marketplace before upgrade, and an unclear unconfigured-budget boundary. The implementation added a terminal gate, completion references and ledger revalidation, metric bounds, controlled V7.2/V7.3 snapshot repair, and task-scoped explicit required mode.
The second round confirmed those root causes were closed and then found that Reviewer results could reference reserved-only or released records. The final implementation accepts only STARTED or COMPLETED reservations and includes a rejection regression. The Reviewer controller still owns rounds and findings only; the unified ledger is the sole total-accounting owner.
The reviews were logically read-only; this report does not claim system-level read-only isolation. The V7.4.1 ten-version compatibility layer is outside this diff.